STATE GOVERNMENT: GOVERNOR
Introduction
The Governor is the constitutional head of a state in India. Just as the President is the head of the Union government, the Governor is the nominal executive authority of the state.
The office of the Governor is provided in Part VI of the Constitution (Articles 153–167). The Governor represents the President in the state and acts as the link between the Union government and the state government.
India follows a parliamentary system of government both at the Centre and in the states. Therefore, although executive power formally rests with the Governor, the real executive authority is exercised by the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister.
However, the Governor plays a crucial constitutional role in maintaining the functioning of the state government and ensuring that governance is carried out according to the Constitution.
Constitutional Provisions
The Constitution contains several provisions related to the Governor.
| Article | Subject |
| Article 153 | Governor of states |
| Article 154 | Executive power of the state |
| Article 155 | Appointment of Governor |
| Article 156 | Term of office |
| Article 157 | Qualifications |
| Article 158 | Conditions of office |
| Article 159 | Oath of office |
| Article 160 | Contingency provisions |
| Article 161 | Pardoning power |
| Article 163 | Council of Ministers to aid and advise |
| Article 164 | Appointment of Chief Minister |
| Article 167 | Duties of Chief Minister regarding Governor |
Governor of States (Article 153)
Article 153 states that there shall be a Governor for each state.
However, the Constitution also allows the same person to act as Governor for two or more states simultaneously.
For example, at different times in Indian constitutional practice, one individual has served as Governor for multiple states.
Appointment of Governor (Article 155)
The Governor is appointed by the President of India.
Thus, unlike the President or members of Parliament, the Governor is not elected by the people.
The appointment of Governors has been a subject of political debate because the Governor is often perceived as representing the interests of the Union government.
Qualifications of Governor (Article 157)
A person must fulfill the following qualifications to become Governor.
- Must be a citizen of India
- Must have completed 35 years of age
Unlike other constitutional offices, the Constitution does not require the Governor to possess any educational or political qualifications.
Conditions of Office (Article 158)
The Constitution lays down several conditions for holding the office of Governor.
No Membership in Legislature
The Governor cannot be a member of:
- Parliament
- State Legislature.
If a member of the legislature is appointed Governor, he or she must resign from that membership.
No Office of Profit
The Governor cannot hold any office of profit under the government.
Official Residence
The Governor is entitled to an official residence known as the Raj Bhavan.
Oath of Office (Article 159)
Before assuming office, the Governor takes an oath administered by the Chief Justice of the High Court of the state.
The oath requires the Governor to:
- preserve and protect the Constitution
- devote himself to the service and well-being of the people of the state.
Term of Office (Article 156)
The Governor holds office for a term of five years.
However, the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President, meaning the President may remove the Governor before the completion of the five-year term.
The Governor may also resign by submitting a resignation to the President of India.
Salary and Allowances
The salary and allowances of the Governor are determined by Parliament.
Currently, the Governor receives:
- ₹3.5 lakh per month (approximately) as salary.
The salary and allowances cannot be reduced during the term of office.
Executive Powers of the Governor
The executive powers of the state are vested in the Governor under Article 154.
These powers are exercised in accordance with the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister.
Appointment Powers
The Governor appoints several important officials in the state.
These include:
- Chief Minister
- Council of Ministers
- Advocate General of the state
- State Election Commissioner
- Chairman and members of State Public Service Commission.
Appointment of Chief Minister
The Governor appoints the Chief Minister, who is usually the leader of the majority party in the State Legislative Assembly.
If no party has a clear majority, the Governor may exercise discretion in selecting a leader who is most likely to command the confidence of the assembly.
Appointment of Council of Ministers
The Governor appoints the Council of Ministers on the advice of the Chief Minister.
The ministers hold office during the pleasure of the Governor, but in practice they serve as long as they enjoy the support of the Chief Minister.
Legislative Powers of the Governor
The Governor is an integral part of the state legislature.
Summoning and Proroguing the Legislature
The Governor has the power to:
- summon the state legislature
- prorogue its sessions.
The Governor may also dissolve the Legislative Assembly.
Address to Legislature
At the beginning of the first session after each general election and at the beginning of every year, the Governor addresses the legislature.
The address outlines the policies and programs of the state government.
Assent to Bills
When a bill is passed by the state legislature, it is presented to the Governor.
The Governor may:
- Give assent
- Withhold assent
- Return the bill for reconsideration
- Reserve the bill for consideration of the President.
Governor’s Role in Jharkhand
Jharkhand is a Fifth Schedule state with large tribal populations and significant Scheduled Areas.
Therefore, the Governor plays an especially important role in tribal administration.
Special Responsibilities in Jharkhand
Under the Fifth Schedule, the Governor of Jharkhand has additional powers.
These include:
- submitting reports to the President regarding administration of Scheduled Areas
- making regulations to protect tribal land
- consulting the Tribal Advisory Council (TAC) on tribal welfare policies.
Tribal Advisory Council (Jharkhand)
Jharkhand has a Tribal Advisory Council as required under the Fifth Schedule.
The council advises the Governor on matters related to:
- tribal development
- land protection
- welfare programs.
Governors of Jharkhand
Since the formation of Jharkhand in 2000, several individuals have served as Governor.
Examples include:
- Prabhat Kumar (first Governor of Jharkhand)
- Draupadi Murmu (later became President of India)
- Ramesh Bais
- C. P. Radhakrishnan (recent Governor).
These Governors have played important roles in political developments in the state.
Importance of the Office of Governor
The Governor serves several important functions.
Constitutional Head of State
The Governor ensures that governance is carried out according to constitutional provisions.
Link between Centre and State
The Governor acts as a bridge between the Union government and the state government.
Protector of Tribal Interests
In states like Jharkhand, the Governor has special responsibilities for protecting tribal communities.
Judicial Powers of the Governor
The Governor possesses certain judicial powers under Article 161 of the Constitution.
These powers relate to the granting of pardons and other forms of clemency to individuals convicted of offences under state laws.
Pardoning Powers
The Governor can grant the following types of relief.
Pardon
A pardon completely removes the punishment and conviction of the offender.
Reprieve
Reprieve means temporary suspension of the execution of a sentence.
Respite
Respite involves awarding a lesser sentence due to special circumstances such as pregnancy or physical disability.
Remission
Remission means reducing the duration of the sentence without changing its nature.
Commutation
Commutation refers to substituting a severe punishment with a lighter one.
For example:
- death sentence may be commuted to life imprisonment.
Limitations of Governor’s Pardoning Power
The Governor’s power under Article 161 has certain limitations.
- The Governor can grant pardons only for offences against state laws.
- The Governor cannot pardon a death sentence awarded under central laws, though the sentence may be commuted.
- The Governor’s power is subject to judicial review.
Financial Powers of the Governor
The Governor plays an important role in the financial administration of the state.
Budget Presentation
The annual financial statement (state budget) is presented in the State Legislature in the name of the Governor.
Money Bills
A Money Bill can be introduced in the State Legislative Assembly only with the prior recommendation of the Governor.
Contingency Fund
The Governor controls the Contingency Fund of the State.
This fund is used to meet unforeseen expenditures.
Finance Commission (State)
The Governor appoints the State Finance Commission every five years.
The Finance Commission reviews the financial position of local bodies and recommends distribution of financial resources between:
- the state government
- Panchayats
- Municipalities.
Discretionary Powers of the Governor
Although the Governor normally acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers, the Constitution grants certain discretionary powers.
These powers allow the Governor to act independently in specific situations.
Situations of Discretion
Appointment of Chief Minister
When no party has a clear majority in the Legislative Assembly, the Governor exercises discretion in selecting a Chief Minister.
Dismissal of Government
If the state government loses majority support, the Governor may dismiss the ministry.
However, the majority must usually be tested on the floor of the Assembly.
Dissolution of Assembly
The Governor may dissolve the Legislative Assembly if the government loses majority and no alternative government can be formed.
Reservation of Bills for President
The Governor may reserve certain bills for the consideration of the President of India.
Recommendation for President’s Rule
The Governor may recommend President’s Rule under Article 356 if the constitutional machinery of the state fails.
Role of Governor in Fifth Schedule Areas (Jharkhand)
Jharkhand is a Fifth Schedule state, and therefore the Governor has special responsibilities under the Constitution.
These powers are provided under Paragraph 5 of the Fifth Schedule.
Powers of Governor in Scheduled Areas
The Governor may:
- Restrict transfer of tribal land to non-tribals
- Regulate money lending in tribal areas
- Modify or suspend laws that may harm tribal interests.
These regulations require approval of the President.
Protection of Tribal Land
In Jharkhand, tribal land is protected by special laws such as:
- Chotanagpur Tenancy Act (1908)
- Santhal Pargana Tenancy Act (1949)
The Governor plays a supervisory role in ensuring that these laws are implemented properly.
Annual Report to the President
The Governor must submit an annual report to the President regarding the administration of Scheduled Areas.
Based on this report, the Union government may issue directions to the state.
This provision ensures that tribal welfare policies receive national attention.
Important Supreme Court Judgments on Governor’s Powers
Several landmark judgments have clarified the powers and limitations of the Governor.
Shamsher Singh vs State of Punjab (1974)
The Supreme Court held that:
- The Governor is a constitutional head.
- The Governor must act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, except in situations where the Constitution explicitly allows discretion.
This judgment reinforced the principle of parliamentary democracy.
S. R. Bommai Case (1994)
Although primarily related to President’s Rule, this case also affected the powers of Governors.
The Supreme Court ruled that:
- The majority of a government must be tested on the floor of the assembly.
- Governors should not arbitrarily recommend President’s Rule.
This decision reduced misuse of Article 356.
Nabam Rebia Case (2016)
In this case concerning Arunachal Pradesh, the Supreme Court held that:
- The Governor cannot interfere excessively in legislative proceedings.
- The Governor must act within constitutional limits.
Controversies Regarding the Office of Governor
The office of Governor has often been criticized for several reasons.
Political Appointment
Governors are appointed by the Union government.
Opposition parties often accuse the central government of appointing politically loyal individuals as Governors.
Misuse of Discretionary Powers
Governors have sometimes been accused of misusing discretionary powers, especially in situations involving:
- formation of governments
- imposition of President’s Rule.
Role in Centre–State Relations
Some critics argue that Governors sometimes act as agents of the central government, which may undermine federal principles.
Recommendations of Commissions
Several commissions have examined the role of Governors.
Sarkaria Commission (1983)
The Sarkaria Commission recommended:
- Governors should be eminent individuals with no active political affiliation.
- Governors should not be involved in local politics of the state.
- The Governor should act as a neutral constitutional authority.
Punchhi Commission (2007)
The Punchhi Commission recommended:
- clear guidelines for the use of discretionary powers
- consultation with the Chief Minister before appointing Governors.
Importance of the Governor in Jharkhand
The role of the Governor in Jharkhand is particularly significant because:
- the state has large Scheduled Areas
- tribal welfare requires constitutional protection.
The Governor’s responsibilities include:
- protecting tribal land rights
- supervising implementation of the Fifth Schedule
- ensuring constitutional governance in the state.
Conclusion
The Governor occupies an important position in the constitutional framework of Indian states. Although the office functions largely as a ceremonial head, the Governor plays a crucial role in maintaining constitutional governance, especially in situations involving political instability or constitutional crises.
In states like Jharkhand, the Governor’s role becomes even more significant because of special responsibilities under the Fifth Schedule for the protection of tribal communities.
However, controversies surrounding the appointment and discretionary powers of Governors highlight the need for reforms to ensure that the office functions as a neutral constitutional authority in the federal system.
For Better Preparation of Prelims & Mains Exam for Jharkhand Section
you can get this book:
STATE GOVERNMENT: CHIEF MINISTER AND COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
Introduction
In the parliamentary system of government adopted by India, the Chief Minister is the real executive head of the state government. While the Governor acts as the constitutional head, the actual powers of administration and governance are exercised by the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister.
The Chief Minister occupies a position similar to that of the Prime Minister at the Union level. The Chief Minister leads the Council of Ministers, formulates government policies, and directs the administration of the state.
The Constitution of India provides the framework for the office of the Chief Minister under Articles 163 and 164, which deal with the Council of Ministers to aid and advise the Governor.
Constitutional Provisions
The Constitution contains several provisions related to the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers.
| Article | Subject |
| Article 163 | Council of Ministers to aid and advise Governor |
| Article 164 | Appointment of Chief Minister and Ministers |
| Article 166 | Conduct of business of state government |
| Article 167 | Duties of Chief Minister |
These provisions collectively establish the structure and functioning of the executive branch of the state government.
Appointment of the Chief Minister
The Governor appoints the Chief Minister.
However, in a parliamentary democracy, this appointment is largely a constitutional formality, because the Governor must appoint the leader of the majority party or coalition in the Legislative Assembly.
Situations in Appointment of Chief Minister
The Governor may face different situations while appointing a Chief Minister.
When a Party Has Clear Majority
If a political party wins a clear majority in the Legislative Assembly, the Governor appoints the leader of that party as the Chief Minister.
This is the most straightforward situation.
In Case of Coalition Government
If no party obtains a majority, multiple parties may form a coalition.
In such cases, the Governor appoints the leader of the coalition as the Chief Minister.
In Case of Hung Assembly
If no party or coalition has a clear majority, the Governor may exercise discretion in selecting a leader who is most likely to secure majority support in the Assembly.
The Chief Minister must then prove majority through a floor test in the Legislative Assembly.
Qualification of Chief Minister
The Constitution does not explicitly mention qualifications for the Chief Minister.
However, since the Chief Minister must be a member of the state legislature, the following conditions apply:
- Must be a citizen of India
- Must be at least 25 years old (for Legislative Assembly)
- Must not hold any office of profit.
If a person who is not a member of the legislature is appointed Chief Minister, he or she must become a member of the legislature within six months.
Term of Office
The Constitution does not specify a fixed tenure for the Chief Minister.
The Chief Minister holds office as long as he or she enjoys the confidence of the Legislative Assembly.
If the Chief Minister loses majority support, the government must resign.
Powers and Functions of the Chief Minister
The Chief Minister is the most important executive authority in the state government.
The powers of the Chief Minister can be understood under several categories.
1. Head of the Council of Ministers
The Chief Minister is the leader of the Council of Ministers.
He or she:
- selects ministers
- allocates portfolios
- coordinates the activities of different departments.
The Chief Minister may also recommend the removal of ministers.
2. Link Between Governor and Council of Ministers
The Chief Minister acts as the principal channel of communication between the Governor and the Council of Ministers.
The Governor interacts with the state government mainly through the Chief Minister.
3. Leader of the State Legislature
The Chief Minister is usually the leader of the majority party in the Legislative Assembly.
As the leader of the house, the Chief Minister:
- directs legislative business
- ensures passage of government bills
- represents the government during debates.
4. Policy Formulation
The Chief Minister plays a key role in formulating state policies and development programs.
Major policy decisions of the state government are taken under the leadership of the Chief Minister.
5. Administrative Head of the State
The Chief Minister exercises significant influence over the state administration.
Key responsibilities include:
- supervising government departments
- coordinating administrative activities
- ensuring implementation of government policies.
6. Role in Planning and Development
The Chief Minister plays an important role in economic planning and development.
The Chief Minister often represents the state in meetings with:
- the Prime Minister
- central government ministries
- NITI Aayog.
Duties of Chief Minister (Article 167)
Article 167 specifies the duties of the Chief Minister with respect to the Governor.
The Chief Minister must:
- Communicate decisions of the Council of Ministers to the Governor
- Provide information requested by the Governor
- Submit matters for consideration of the Council of Ministers when required by the Governor.
These provisions ensure coordination between the Governor and the state government.
Relationship Between Governor and Chief Minister
The relationship between the Governor and the Chief Minister is a crucial aspect of state governance.
In theory, the Governor acts on the advice of the Chief Minister and Council of Ministers.
However, in certain situations the Governor may exercise discretionary powers.
Cooperation in Governance
In normal circumstances, the Governor and Chief Minister work together to ensure smooth administration of the state.
The Governor performs ceremonial duties while the Chief Minister exercises real executive authority.
Role in Constitutional Crisis
During political instability, the Governor may play an important role.
Examples include:
- appointing a Chief Minister in case of a hung assembly
- recommending President’s Rule.
Chief Minister in Jharkhand
Jharkhand became a separate state on 15 November 2000.
Since then, the state has witnessed several political changes and coalition governments.
Chief Ministers of Jharkhand
Some notable Chief Ministers of Jharkhand include:
| Chief Minister | Party |
| Babulal Marandi | BJP |
| Arjun Munda | BJP |
| Shibu Soren | JMM |
| Madhu Koda | Independent |
| Raghubar Das | BJP |
| Hemant Soren | JMM |
These leaders have played significant roles in shaping the political and economic development of Jharkhand.
Role of Chief Minister in Jharkhand’s Development
The Chief Minister of Jharkhand plays a critical role in addressing key challenges faced by the state.
These include:
- tribal development
- mining and industrial policies
- land rights
- rural development.
Jharkhand’s large tribal population makes governance particularly complex.
The Chief Minister must ensure that development policies align with constitutional safeguards such as the Fifth Schedule and PESA Act.
COUNCIL OF MINISTERS (STATE EXECUTIVE)
Introduction
The Council of Ministers is the real executive authority in a state government. While the Governor is the constitutional head of the state, the actual powers of administration are exercised by the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister.
The Council of Ministers is responsible for formulating policies, implementing laws, and administering government departments.
The constitutional provisions related to the Council of Ministers are mainly contained in Articles 163 and 164 of the Constitution.
Constitutional Provisions
| Article | Subject |
| Article 163 | Council of Ministers to aid and advise Governor |
| Article 164 | Appointment of ministers |
| Article 166 | Conduct of business of state government |
| Article 167 | Duties of Chief Minister |
These provisions define the structure and functioning of the state executive.
Article 163 – Aid and Advice
Article 163 states that the Governor shall act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister, except in matters where the Constitution allows the Governor to act in his discretion.
Thus, the Council of Ministers is the real decision-making authority in the state government.
Article 164 – Appointment of Ministers
According to Article 164:
- The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor.
- Other ministers are appointed by the Governor on the advice of the Chief Minister.
- Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the Governor.
However, in practice ministers remain in office as long as they enjoy the confidence of the Chief Minister and the Legislative Assembly.
Composition of the Council of Ministers
The Council of Ministers consists of several ministers who are responsible for different government departments.
These ministers collectively assist the Chief Minister in governing the state.
Categories of Ministers
Although the Constitution does not specify categories of ministers, in practice the Council of Ministers is divided into several levels.
1. Cabinet Ministers
Cabinet Ministers are the senior-most members of the Council of Ministers.
They head major departments such as:
- finance
- home affairs
- education
- agriculture.
Cabinet Ministers participate in Cabinet meetings, where important policy decisions are taken.
2. Ministers of State
Ministers of State are junior ministers who assist Cabinet Ministers.
They may either:
- work under a Cabinet Minister, or
- handle independent departments.
3. Deputy Ministers
Deputy Ministers assist Cabinet Ministers or Ministers of State.
They do not usually participate in Cabinet meetings.
Cabinet vs Council of Ministers
The terms Cabinet and Council of Ministers are often used interchangeably, but they are not identical.
| Basis | Cabinet | Council of Ministers |
| Size | Smaller group | Larger body |
| Composition | Senior ministers | All ministers |
| Function | Policy decision-making | Implementation and administration |
| Meetings | Regular cabinet meetings | Not all members attend |
The Cabinet is the core decision-making body, while the Council of Ministers includes all ministers.
Collective Responsibility
One of the most important principles of the parliamentary system is collective responsibility.
Article 164 states that the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly.
This means that:
- all ministers must support the decisions of the government
- if the Legislative Assembly passes a vote of no confidence, the entire Council of Ministers must resign.
Collective responsibility ensures unity and accountability in government.
Individual Responsibility
Ministers are also individually responsible for the functioning of their respective departments.
If a minister fails to perform effectively or loses the confidence of the Chief Minister, he or she may be removed from office.
Size of Council of Ministers
Initially, the Constitution did not specify any limit on the size of the Council of Ministers.
This sometimes led to excessively large ministries.
To address this issue, the 91st Constitutional Amendment Act (2003) introduced a limit.
Provision of 91st Constitutional Amendment
According to this amendment:
- The total number of ministers in the Council of Ministers must not exceed 15% of the total strength of the Legislative Assembly.
- However, the number of ministers must not be less than 12.
This amendment was introduced to reduce political patronage and improve administrative efficiency.
Role of the Council of Ministers
The Council of Ministers performs several important functions in the state government.
Policy Formulation
The Council of Ministers formulates policies related to:
- economic development
- social welfare
- education
- infrastructure.
Legislative Functions
The Council of Ministers is responsible for introducing most of the bills in the State Legislature.
Ministers also participate in legislative debates and explain government policies.
Administrative Functions
The Council of Ministers supervises the functioning of government departments and ensures implementation of laws and policies.
Financial Functions
The state budget is prepared by the Council of Ministers.
Financial policies and taxation proposals are also formulated by the government.
Council of Ministers in Jharkhand
Jharkhand has experienced frequent coalition governments since its formation in 2000.
Coalition politics has significantly influenced the composition and functioning of the Council of Ministers.
Examples of Coalition Governments in Jharkhand
Several governments in Jharkhand were formed through alliances between different political parties.
Examples include:
- JMM–Congress alliance governments
- BJP-led coalition governments
Coalition governments often require careful distribution of ministerial portfolios among coalition partners.
Challenges in State Governance (Jharkhand Context)
The Council of Ministers in Jharkhand faces several governance challenges.
Tribal Development
Jharkhand has a large tribal population.
The government must implement policies that protect tribal rights under the Fifth Schedule and PESA Act.
Natural Resource Management
Jharkhand is rich in minerals such as:
- coal
- iron ore
- bauxite.
The state government must balance economic development with environmental protection and tribal rights.
Rural Development
Many regions of Jharkhand are economically underdeveloped.
The Council of Ministers must prioritize:
- rural infrastructure
- education
- healthcare.
Importance of Council of Ministers
The Council of Ministers plays a central role in the functioning of the state government.
Its importance lies in:
- ensuring democratic accountability
- implementing government policies
- coordinating administrative functions.
The effectiveness of state governance largely depends on the leadership of the Chief Minister and the collective functioning of the Council of Ministers.
Conclusion
The Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers together form the core executive authority of the state government. While the Governor serves as the constitutional head, the real powers of governance lie with the Council of Ministers.
The principles of collective responsibility, cabinet decision-making, and legislative accountability ensure that the executive remains responsible to the elected representatives of the people.
In states like Jharkhand, the role of the Council of Ministers becomes particularly significant because of the need to address complex issues such as tribal welfare, resource management, and economic development.
For Better Preparation of Prelims & Mains Exam for Jharkhand Section
you can get this book: